As the days grow shorter and the air crisper, autumn ushers in not just a change in weather, but a shift in our taste buds’ preferences. For years, pumpkin spice has reigned supreme as the quintessential flavor of fall, but new research suggests that its throne might be under threat. According to a recent survey of 2,000 U.S. adults commissioned by Post Honey Bunches of Oats, a surprising 58% of respondents believe that there are superior, lesser-known heroes waiting to be crowned as the true flavors of the season.

The survey delved deep into Americans’ seasonal palate preferences, revealing a growing weariness with the ubiquitous pumpkin spice. A significant 45% admitted to feeling fatigued by the basic pumpkin spice flavors, paving the way for alternatives that offer a more exciting seasonal experience. Leading this flavor revolution are cinnamon, salted caramel, and candy apple, all of which surpassed pumpkin spice in popularity among respondents.

Cinnamon emerged as the undisputed champion, with 39% of respondents declaring it their top fall flavor, closely followed by salted caramel at 37% and candy apple at 36%. These flavors not only tantalize taste buds but also embody the essence of fall, resonating deeply with those who cherish seasonal traditions and culinary delights.

The survey highlighted generational differences in taste preferences, with millennials proving to be the most vocal advocates for diverse autumnal flavors. A significant 32% of millennials confessed to engaging in heated debates over their preferred fall tastes, compared to just 19% of Gen Xers. This generational divide underscores a broader cultural shift towards embracing variety and innovation in seasonal cuisine.

While some flavors are deemed exclusive to fall—pumpkin spice being the prime example—others like cinnamon and salted caramel enjoy year-round appeal, according to 35% of respondents. This flexibility allows enthusiasts to savor their favorite flavors regardless of the season, blurring the lines between seasonal and perennial culinary delights.

Beyond flavors, the survey captured a profound longing for the autumnal season itself. A remarkable 36% of respondents admitted to eagerly anticipating fall more than any other season, citing reasons ranging from cooler weather and holiday festivities to the evocative scents that define the season. For many, fall represents a cherished time of transition, marked by nature’s vibrant hues and the promise of cozy gatherings.

As perceptions evolve and palates diversify, the call to embrace a broader spectrum of fall flavors grows louder. Erin Crawford, Senior Brand Manager at Post Honey Bunches of Oats, reflects on these findings: “Whether you’re a longtime enthusiast or just discovering your seasonal favorite, it’s evident that the era of pumpkin spice dominance may be waning. It’s time to explore new tastes and celebrate the rich tapestry of flavors that define autumn.”

As we bid farewell to pumpkin spice’s monopoly on fall flavors, we welcome a new era of culinary exploration and appreciation. Whether you find solace in the warmth of cinnamon, the decadence of salted caramel, or the nostalgic sweetness of candy apple, autumn beckons with a cornucopia of tastes waiting to be savored. As seasons change and tastes evolve, one thing remains clear: the journey through fall’s flavors is as delightful as the season itself.

—

**Survey Methodology:**

This survey was conducted by Talker Research on behalf of Post Honey Bunches of Oats, gathering insights from 2,000 randomly selected U.S. adults between May 21 and May 24, 2024. The survey adhered to rigorous standards set by the Market Research Society (MRS) and the European Society for Opinion and Marketing Research (ESOMAR), ensuring reliability and validity in its findings.